Any Chance Gerrit Cole Lives Up to Expectations With the Yankees?

Of course, now comes the hard part—living up to the expectations that come with making $324 million.
Posted in: Op-edSports News
December 19, 2019 1:07 AM UTC

Fans of the New York Yankees are accustomed to seeing their team in the World Series. But they have only been there once in the last decade (2009). They have been close in two of the previous three seasons (2017 and ’19) only to lose both times to the Houston Astros in the ALCS.

It’s a trend that has to change. So, what does the organization do to make it happen? They spend $324 million to acquire Houston’s best pitcher and arguably the best in baseball, Gerrit Cole. The deal was announced on Dec. 11 and made official Dec. 18.

Destiny, Gerrit Cole? Really?

During his introductory press conference, Cole called his signing with the Yankees destiny, a dream he has had since he was a kid.

Comments like that are standard when guys sign with the Yankees (or any new team). What player wouldn’t want to join a team as historic as the Yankees? To be on the same club as some of the game’s all-time greats has to be considered an honor.

It doesn’t hurt that the Yankees happen to pay better than anyone else in the league, either.

But to illustrate his love for the team, he brought with him a sign he held up while attending a game during the 2001 World Series:

As could be expected, some people on social media didn‘t believe him. But then others found proof:

A young Gerrit Cole proclaims his allegiance to the Yankees in 2001 at the World Series. | Source: Twitter

Of course, the skeptics of Twitter still called foul and said it wasn’t the same sign. Some also brought up that he had a chance to sign with the Yankees in 2008 when they made him the No. 28 pick of the draft. He chose to go to college instead (UCLA).

Does it really matter? It was a cool moment and showed that signing with the Yankees was about more than just the ridiculous paycheck.

Ready For The Tough Part, Gerrit Cole?

Of course, now comes the hard part—living up to the expectations that come with making $324 million. When a guy becomes the highest-paid pitcher in the game, it is fair to assume he should win a lot of games.

The Yankees are going to expect it of him, too. If he doesn’t deliver, they are likely going to let him have it much like they let Giancarlo Stanton have it during his disastrous debut (five strikeouts) in the Bronx:

If Cole has as dire a home debut as Stanton did, fans will likely boo him too. But the real question is what it will take for the deal to be worthwhile at the end of the season.

Many fans will say the World Series, but to make that claim would be unfair. Yes, Cole can help them get there, but everyone else has to do their jobs as well for the team to make the World Series, let alone win it.

But on an individual level, the Yankees haven’t had a 20+ game-winner since CC Sabathia won 21 games in 2010. The last Yankee to win the AL Cy Young was Roger Clemens in 2001.

If he does both, there is a very good chance the Yankees will be in the World Series next year. Should they fail to make it but he still hits both marks, then it will certainly not be because he didn’t earn his money.

Gerelyn Terzo edited this article for If you see a breach of our Code of Ethics or Rights and Duties of the Editor or find a factual, spelling, or grammar error, please contact us.

Last modified: January 22, 2020 11:40 PM UTC

Show comments
Travis Pulver @FatManWriting

Travis graduated from Ball State University in Muncie, Indiana, with a master's in Political Science. Prior to that, he attended IU Purdue in Indianapolis, Indiana, where he earned his bachelor's degree in Political Science and earned his first degree at Texas A & M in Galveston, TX, a BS in Maritime Administration. You can contact him on Twitter at @FatManWriting. Over the last few years, Travis has worked for several news-oriented sites that focused on sports, especially football, baseball, basketball, and to a lesser extent, boxing and MMA. Having grown up in the football-crazed state of Texas, football is his first love. According to his mother, he was more excited to watch NFL and college games as a baby than Sesame Street or Mickey Mouse. His passion for sports quickly spread to baseball (favorite team is the Houston Astros), basketball, and track and field as a kid. It wasn’t until his college years that he discovered the tremendous game of rugby. He currently lives in the United States in Indiana (is a basketball fan but hates going to the Indy 500) with his wife and two adorable kids.