SEC Warms to Bitcoin ETF Amid Price-Manipulation Fears

Samantha Chang @Samantha_Chang
September 9, 2019 22:13 UTC

SEC Chairman Jay Clayton says the agency is inching closer to finally approving a bitcoin ETF. However, he warns that more work needs to be done to deter price manipulation and ensure a transparent market.

Clayton made the assertions during a CNBC interview with Bob Pisani (video below). Pisani asked if we’re any closer to seeing a bitcoin ETF soon.

Clayton responded by saying, “Yes. But there’s work left to be done.”

SEC Fears ‘Significant’ Bitcoin Price Manipulation

Specifically, Jay Clayton says the Securities and Exchange Commission wants more information about custody as well as assurances against price manipulation.

“How do we know that we can custody and have a hold of these crypto assets?” Clayton said. “That’s a key question. An even harder question — given that they trade on largely unregulated exchanges is — ‘How can we be sure that those prices aren’t subject to significant manipulation?”

The SEC chairman admits that progress has been made on those fronts. However, he warns that “people needed to answer those hard questions for us to be comfortable that this was the appropriate type of product.”

‘Crypto Mom’: SEC Should’ve Approved Bitcoin ETF

In August, the SEC again delayed making a final decision on three bitcoin ETF applications. While a delay is better than an outright rejection, the move frustrated many in the crypto industry.

Meanwhile, SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce says the agency should’ve approved a bitcoin ETF already. In June, Peirce blasted the agency for being an out-of-touch dinosaur.

Peirce has repeatedly torched the SEC for its glacial approach toward approving a bitcoin ETF. She says the agency’s timidity puts it in the position of being a babysitter for investors.

Peirce Scolds SEC: Stop Being Lame

Peirce noted that the SEC has been very closed-minded when it comes to embracing innovation. “The agency is old and has not historically been great with innovation,” she quipped.

Hester Peirce is one of five SEC commissioners. They each have differing views on crypto. Peirce was affectionately nicknamed “Crypto Mom” because of her pro-crypto positions.

In July 2018, Peirce was the only SEC commissioner who voted to approve the bitcoin ETF application submitted by the Winklevoss twins, Tyler and Cameron.

The rejections — in March 2017 and again in June 2018  — cited the twins’ failure to demonstrate how their bitcoin ETF could prevent market manipulation.

The SEC rejected the Winklevoss twins’ bitcoin ETF applications in 2017 and 2018. | Image: Gemini/Twitter

Van Eck: Bitcoin ETF could fortify US economy

Gabor Gurbacs, of investment management firm VanEck, says the SEC should approve a bitcoin ETF soon because it could be a major driver of the U.S. economy for the next decade.

“We are waiting finally for regulators to approve a bitcoin ETF, which would bring digital assets under the regulated American capital market,” Gurbacs said. “This could be, for the next decade, the driver of our economy.”

Gurbacs says the United States should harness these technologies to upgrade its payments systems and capital markets infrastructure. He contends that doing this would make America the world leader in the budding digital economy.

Last modified: September 10, 2019 19:11 UTC

Samantha Chang @Samantha_Chang

Samantha Chang is a New York City-based financial editor who writes about crypto and business at . She is a law school grad and an alum of the University of Pennsylvania. You can reach her on Twitter at Samantha Chang or email her at schang121@juno.com.