Visa, Mastercard, Coinbase and BlackRock Unite Behind Open USD (OUSD): The First Real Threat to USDT and USDC?
Key Takeaways
Jeremy Allaire published a lengthy X post on July 1 that was careful, pointed, and devastating in sequence. He began by explaining stablecoins as platform and network-effect businesses that tend toward winner-take-most outcomes, and spent the rest of the post explaining why OUSD’s model undermines the very infrastructure required to compete at that level.
His critique landed on three specific targets:
+81
+76
+217
The detail that gives Allaire’s critique its greatest credibility is that Circle is not speculating about consortium failure. It has experienced it firsthand. USDC launched in 2018 under the Centre Consortium, a joint governance structure between Circle and Coinbase. By August 2023, Circle dissolved the Centre and assumed sole governance of USDC, ending the shared model after five years.
Circle has since turned that experience into a competitive argument. The company now argues that stablecoins governed by a single issuer can move faster, align incentives more effectively, and scale more efficiently than consortium-led models. The Centre experience is the strongest evidence supporting Allaire’s thesis.
The historical record backs Allaire’s case at every data point. Meta’s Diem, formerly known as Libra, assembled a founding consortium in 2019 that included Visa, Mastercard, Uber, and dozens of other companies. Regulatory pressure and internal coordination failures collapsed the project before it launched commercially.
Paxos’s Global Dollar Network (USDG) is the closest operational precedent to OUSD. Despite backing from major financial institutions and a revenue-sharing consortium model, USDG has grown to only about $3 billion in supply, far below USDC’s roughly $77 billion. That gap illustrates how assembling large partners does not automatically create liquidity or network effects.
This ceiling, is what ARK Invest Director of Research Lorenzo Valente called the “cold-start problem” that consolidated liquidity creates for every new entrant regardless of the size of its backer list.
OUSD’s 140-name backer roster contains two tension points that no amount of consortium press releases can paper over.
BlackRock manages the Circle Reserve Fund that backs USDC’s reserves, making it simultaneously the custodian of Circle’s primary asset and a financial backer of its most direct competitor. That is not a conflict that resolves cleanly on either side.
The Coinbase dynamic is sharper still. Coinbase’s distribution agreement with Circle, filed as an exhibit to Coinbase’s 10-K, runs on an initial three-year term from its August 18, 2023 effective date with automatic renewals contingent on Coinbase meeting product and reseller thresholds. That agreement comes up for renewal in approximately six weeks, generating close to 20% of Coinbase’s total revenue.
Coinbase is simultaneously a founding OUSD backer. Allaire said publicly that “our stablecoin partnership with Coinbase remains as strong as ever,” a statement that reads less like reassurance and more like a negotiating position delivered in public before a contract renewal deadline.
Bernstein analysts flagged the Coinbase participation in OUSD as something that “has raised eyebrows,” but maintained their Outperform rating on CRCL and a $190 price target, calling OUSD the most formidable challenge the Circle-Tether duopoly has faced while also noting that coordinating 140-plus partners represents a considerable operational undertaking. William Blair kept its own Outperform and called the selloff an overreaction, echoing Allaire’s core argument that logos are not liquidity.
CRCL closed at $62.63 on June 30, down 17.55%, a combined selloff driven by OUSD’s announcement and Circle’s removal from five FTSE Russell Growth indexes during the 2026 annual reconstitution. The stock recovered 2.44% pre-market on July 2.
Whether OUSD eventually challenges USDC’s 80% transaction share depends on whether 140 logos can become 140 active distribution partners on a timetable that actually pressures Circle’s business before the August renewal is signed, sealed, and extended.
internal-linking title=”Top Trending Crypto Articles” url1=”https://www.ccn.com/crypto-exchanges/” text1=”Check Out Our Recommended Exchanges Here” label1=”Best Exchanges” url2=”https://www.ccn.com/how-to-buy-crypto-with-credit-card/” text2=”How To Buy Crypto with a Credit Card Now” label2=”Buy Crypto Fast” url3=”https://www.ccn.com/crypto-gambling/” text3=”See Our Picks for the Best Crypto Gambling Sites” label3=”Safe Crypto Gambling”]