Peter Schiff Blasts Michael Saylor, Says Strategy’s MSTR Will Deliver ‘Worse Returns’ After 50% 2025 Crash — Will It?
Michael Saylor’s Strategy could fall to $23 a share, chart analyst Aksel Kibar has warned, a drop of about 76% from Tuesday’s reported close of $96.50.
The warning follows Strategy’s disclosure last week that it raised $244.7 million by selling common shares, using $206.3 million of the proceeds to buy back preferred stock and $33.4 million to buy Bitcoin.
+81
+76
+217
Strategy issued nearly 2.09 million MSTR shares between Nov. 9 and Nov. 15.
For every dollar it raised, about 84 cents went to STRC buybacks, 14 cents went to Bitcoin, and 2 cents went into cash.
The previous week, about 66 cents of every dollar raised from common-stock sales went to STRC repurchases.
The company added $21.8 million in interest income to fund the buybacks, bringing total STRC repurchases to $228.1 million.
Its $33.4 million Bitcoin purchase added 485 BTC, taking its holdings to 850,849 BTC.
Chart analyst Aksel Kibar said in a post on X that Strategy stock had broken below the neckline of a bearish head-and-shoulders pattern near $101.
MSTR rebounded sharply, but Kibar said the rally failed to clear the pattern’s right shoulder, the prior high he was watching for a move that would invalidate his bearish outlook.
“Pattern is intact with a price target of 23,” Kibar wrote.
Kibar also pointed to Bitcoin’s trading range between $60,000 and $82,800.
He said a break below the lower end could see Bitcoin resume its decline.
At $23, Strategy would need to sell about 4.2 times as many common shares to raise the same amount it could at $96.50.
That creates two risks for MSTR holders.
A drop in Bitcoin would cut the value of Strategy’s holdings, while a lower share price would make future fundraising more dilutive.
Strategy also faces potential selling from index funds.
MSCI is set to remove the company from its USA Index after the Nov. 30 close, and funds tracking the benchmark would generally have to sell their MSTR shares.
The recent comments follow gold advocate Peter Schiff warning that a deeper Bitcoin sell-off could put pressure on both classes of Strategy stock.
On Nov. 9, the longtime Bitcoin critic called Strategy’s STRC preferred shares “dead” and argued that further losses in Bitcoin would spur more selling.
“A 12% yield won’t be nearly enough to offset the risk,” he wrote.
Five days later, Schiff turned to Strategy’s common shares.
He said a break below $50,000 could send Bitcoin back to its 2022 low below $16,500 before year-end.
A retest of that low, he said, would mean “curtains for $MSTR.”
Strategy CEO Phong Le said in October that the company had “demonstrated its commitment to returning STRC to health” through buybacks and a larger pool of dollar assets.
Management plans to recommend keeping STRC’s annual dividend rate at 12% until the shares trade consistently near $100.
As of Nov. 15, Strategy held $4.75 billion in a dollar reserve set aside for preferred dividends and interest on its debt.