Key Takeaways
- In-kind redemptions align crypto ETFs with mainstream commodity ETF structures, improving efficiency and reducing costs.
- Institutions gain flexibility, and tax efficiency increases, making crypto exposure more appealing for long-term allocators.
- ETFs can now better track spot market prices with reduced premium/discount volatility.
- This move could be the first step toward allowing more asset classes (like Solana or tokenized commodities) to have ETF structures with in-kind provisions.
On July 29, 2025, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) took a landmark step by approving in-kind creations and redemptions for crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs), including those holding Bitcoin and Ethereum.
This is more than a technical change in how ETFs operate; it’s a pivotal moment in the evolution of regulated crypto markets.
Let’s learn more about it.
The SEC’s Previous Stance: Cash-Only Redemptions
Before this decision, all U.S.-listed crypto ETFs were subject to cash-only redemption rules. When investors redeemed their ETF shares, authorized participants (APs) were required to liquidate the underlying crypto assets for cash before delivering redemption proceeds.
This approach was rooted in concerns over custody, market manipulation, and operational risks in crypto markets. The SEC feared that directly handling crypto during redemptions could increase systemic risk and complicate market oversight. As a result:
- ETFs needed intermediaries to sell crypto on spot markets.
- This often led to higher costs, trading slippage, and tax inefficiencies.
- Institutional investors found these products less flexible compared to traditional commodity ETFs like Gold or Silver.
For years, issuers like BlackRock (IBIT), Grayscale, and ARK 21Shares lobbied for parity with other commodity-based ETFs, arguing that crypto infrastructure has matured. The SEC’s latest ruling signals acknowledgment of those advancements.
What Are In-Kind Redemptions?
In traditional ETF markets, in-kind redemptions allow authorized participants (the institutions responsible for creating and redeeming ETF shares) to exchange ETF shares for the underlying assets directly, instead of settling in cash.
Example:
- Old model (Cash redemption) → ETF sells Bitcoin for USD → AP receives USD → Investor pays taxes on crypto sales immediately.
- New model (In-kind redemption) → AP redeems ETF shares and receives Bitcoin directly → No forced sale, no immediate taxable event.
This mechanism is standard for most ETFs that hold physical commodities like gold or baskets of equities, ensuring efficient market operations.
Why Does In-Kind Redemptions Matter for Crypto ETFs?
In-kind redemptions reduce tax inefficiencies, lower transaction costs, and tighten bid-ask spreads — all critical for institutional investors. By allowing crypto to be exchanged directly rather than sold for cash, this mechanism makes ETFs more scalable, competitive, and aligned with traditional financial products like gold or equity ETFs.
- Lower costs: No need to sell assets in the open market, which reduces trading fees and slippage.
- Tax efficiency: Institutions can hold crypto rather than being forced to sell, deferring capital gains taxes until they choose to dispose of the assets.
- Improved pricing: In-kind arbitrage tightens the ETF’s price to its net asset value (NAV).
- Greater institutional appeal: Institutions now have a structure similar to other asset classes they are already comfortable with.
| Features |
Before (Cash-Only Redemptions) |
After (In-Kind Redemptions) |
| Redemption mechanism |
Sell crypto → pay out cash |
Deliver crypto directly |
| Transaction costs |
High (market slippage, fees) |
Lower (direct transfers) |
| NAV tracking |
Looser (premium/discount issues) |
Tighter (faster arbitrage) |
| Tax treatment |
Immediate taxable event |
Deferred until crypto sale |
| Institutional appeal |
Moderate (structural frictions) |
High (aligned with commodity ETF norms) |
How In-Kind Creations & Redemptions Work?
Think of it like a fruit basket store (ETP) and wholesale suppliers (Authorized Participants or APs):
In-Kind Creation:
- Instead of paying cash, the supplier (AP) delivers actual fruit (like apples, bananas, oranges = Bitcoin, Ether, etc.) to the store.
- In return, the store gives the supplier fruit baskets (ETP shares) representing that exact fruit collection.
In-Kind Redemption:
- When the supplier wants fruit back, they return the fruit baskets (ETP shares) to the store.
- The store unpacks the basket and gives back the actual fruit (crypto assets) to the supplier.
Why is this better than using cash?
If the supplier only used cash:
- They would give money to the store.
- The store would have to go buy the fruit from the market (which takes time and has fees).
By swapping fruit for fruit baskets directly, there are fewer steps, lower costs, and faster transactions.
For investors, this means more efficient trading and potentially lower fees.
In-Kind ETF Reform Could Unlock $50B in Flows
A regulatory shift is set to reshape crypto ETFs in the U.S. by removing long‑standing operational frictions that kept major institutions on the sidelines. The change is expected to boost trading efficiency, attract significant new capital, and bring U.S. markets closer to global peers. Industry leaders are already positioned to benefit as analysts project billions in fresh inflows over the coming year.
- A big win for institutional adoption: Institutional allocators such as pension funds, hedge funds, and sovereign wealth funds have historically been hesitant to adopt crypto ETFs because of operational inefficiencies. This rule change lowers the barriers.
- Potential liquidity boost: With tighter spreads and reduced redemption frictions, ETFs are expected to see increased daily trading volumes and tighter bid-ask spreads, making them more competitive with direct crypto markets.
- Alignment with global standards: Markets like Canada and parts of Europe already allow in-kind mechanisms for their crypto ETFs. This move puts U.S. markets on a level playing field, reducing the risk of capital flight to foreign-listed ETFs.
- Impact on ETF issuers: Industry leaders like BlackRock (IBIT), Fidelity (FBTC), and ARK 21Shares (ARKB) stand to benefit significantly, as operational efficiencies will likely attract more inflows. Analysts estimate up to $50 billion in additional institutional flows over the next 12–18 months.
Conclusion
The SEC’s approval of in-kind creations and redemptions for crypto ETFs is more than a technical rule change, it represents regulatory maturity and market evolution. By removing structural inefficiencies, ETFs holding Bitcoin and Ethereum can now compete on equal footing with traditional commodity ETFs.
For investors, this means tighter spreads, better tax efficiency, and a stronger case for institutional adoption. For the crypto industry, it’s a vote of confidence from regulators that crypto markets have evolved to the point of handling sophisticated financial structures responsibly.
Bottom line: If 2024 was the year crypto ETFs entered the mainstream, then 2025 might be remembered as the year they became truly institutional.
FAQs
In-kind redemption means ETF shares are redeemed for the underlying asset (e.g., Bitcoin or Ethereum) instead of cash. Cash redemptions require selling the underlying asset for cash, which can create inefficiencies and taxable events. In-kind processes are more efficient and tax-friendly.
No. Only authorized participants (APs), typically large financial institutions, can execute in-kind transactions. Retail investors still buy and sell ETF shares on exchanges in cash.
Indirectly, yes. With reduced slippage and transaction costs, ETF issuers may pass savings onto investors over time, or at least maintain competitive fee levels while improving liquidity.
Potentially. With proven operational models and regulatory comfort, ETF issuers could push for additional crypto products (e.g., Solana or Polygon). However, each asset must meet regulatory scrutiny on liquidity, custody, and market integrity.
The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as, financial advice. We do not make any warranties regarding the completeness, reliability, or accuracy of this information. All investments involve risk, and past performance does not guarantee future results. We recommend consulting a financial advisor before making any investment decisions.
Onkar Singh has three years of experience as a digital finance content creator. Throughout his career, he has collaborated with various DeFi projects and crypto media outlets. In his leisure time, he enjoys fitness activities at the gym and watching movies across different genres. Balancing his professional and personal interests, Onkar continues to contribute to the digital finance landscape while pursuing his hobbies.
Easy 
