Don’t Let Christophe Gans Ruin Silent Hill Again

Christophe Gans wants to thrust another dagger into the heart of the Silent Hill franchise by making another film. Please don't let him.

The Silent Hill movies betray an utter misunderstanding of the source material. | Source: REUTERS / Mario Anzuoni

  • Silent Hill was first adapted for the silver screen in 2006.
  • Both of the franchise’s movies earned poor marks from critics.
  • The director from the first movie wants to drag the series through the trash heap again.

French director Christophe Gans stuck a dagger in the reputation of one of gaming’s most revered horror franchises when he released Silent Hill – the movie – in 2006.

Then someone else made a sequel that was somehow even worse. (It did have a silver lining: It starred Jon Snow before his career took off.)

Eight years later, Gans is back to take a second crack at Silent Hill, and he’s determined to deal a mortal blow to one of Konami’s crown jewels.

Why Can’t Hollywood Leave Silent Hill Alone?

The only thing scary about the Silent Hill movies is how awful the reviews were.

The original scored just a 31-out-of-100 on Metacritic. It went from bad to worse after Silent Hill: Revelation came out in 2012. The sequel’s score is only 16, indicating “overwhelming dislike” among critics.

In Gans’ defense, the first film wasn’t completely terrible – at least compared to Revelation. He duplicated much of the style from the video games. Plenty of claustrophobic, isolated scenes made it at least feel like it was related to the source material.

But the story was insane, and the focus on the cult aspects towards the end ruined it.

So of course Silent Hill: Revelation decided to focus purely on the cult themes. No isolation, no claustrophobia. It was a tough watch from start to finish.

At Least It Can’t Be Worse Than Revelation

Luckily for Gans, Silent Hill: Revelation sets a pretty low bar to clear.

All he’d have to do is lean into the creepy visuals from the first movie and resist the urge to succumb to his bizarre infatuation with cult stories.

Of course, he won’t do that.

He’s already said that he wants to plunge deeper into the cult elements that derailed his first swing at Silent Hill [EuroGamer]. Expect him to make gratuitous misuse of oversexualized nurses and Pyramid Head once again.

This gets to the heart of the movie series’ biggest failing: An utter misunderstanding of the source material.

It’s not the cult or the giant metal-headed monsters that haunt us. It’s how the town drills into and takes up permanent residence in the main character’s psyche.

I’m confident this movie will be the worst thing to happen to Silent Hill since Downpour. The only question is whether it will be even worse.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of

Last modified: September 23, 2020 1:33 PM

William Worrall: William Worrall is a professional writer based out of the UK who has been writing about video and tabletop games for over a decade and has covered industry events such as EGX and UKGE. Contact him at, see his LinkedIn profile here.