PayCoin Delisted from amid Fraud Concerns

January 4, 2015 04:45 UTC
Instant altcoin exchange chose to remove PayCoin from their platform.

Today, altcoin exchange formally removed PayCoin (XPY), GAW CEO Josh Garza’s controversial altcoin, from their list of accepted coins. Citing PayCoin’s (alleged) broken promise to buy PayCoins at $20 each, ShapeShift considers PayCoin a fraud.

Also read: Coin-Swap Retires Some Altcoins

PayCoin Delisted from

ShapeShift made the announcement in a Reddit post. They explain that they originally added the coin due to customer demand but decided to remove it after allegations that PayCoin is a scam prompted to conduct a closer investigation.

We’ve looked further into Paycoin, and while there are some criticisms that are superfluous (a coin being “premined” does not necessarily make it a scam, for example), there is one particular issue that we cannot ignore. Josh Garza and the Paycoin admins made a very clear promise – a guarantee – which is that when Paybase opened (a Paycoin marketplace), that Paycoins would be bought there for $20 each. That was a factual promise, made by the creator of the coin.

However, Garza–at least in ShapeShift’s eyes–did not live up to his self-imposed obligation:

And yet here’s what happened: not only did Garza not fulfill his promise to back the value of Paycoin at $20 per coin, but himself and his administrators seem to be actively re-writing history, scrubbing their forum of any mention of that promise. This moves it from fool’s errand to the realm of deception.

The coin now sits around $5, and Garza is claiming he never promised $20. We believe this satisfies a high threshold of evidence as fraud, and so we have decided to remove Paycoin from

It is unclear what affect ShapeShift’s delisting of PayCoin will have on the altcoin–other than adding fuel to its critics’ fires. At present, Cryptsy and Bittrex process most PayCoin trades. However, PayCoin has a guaranteed exchange presence even if other exchanges follow ShapeShift’s lead and remove the coin from their platforms. Josh Garza recently acquired Coin-Swap, and it is unlikely that public pressure could dissuade him from listing his own coin at Coin-Swap.

Images from and Shutterstock.

Last modified: March 17, 2017 08:56 UTC


Josiah is the US Editor at CCN, where he focuses on financial markets. He has written over 2,000 articles since joining CCN in 2014. His work has also been featured on ZeroHedge, Yahoo Finance, and He lives in rural Virginia. Follow him on Twitter @y3llowb1ackbird or email him directly at josiah.wilmoth(at)