SEC Fumbles Ripple Appeal, Missing Crucial Filing Deadline

Key Takeaways

• The SEC has missed an important deadline.
• The securities regulator had two weeks to file its appeal after its notice on Oct. 2.
• The fumble could cost the SEC the Ripple lawsuit.

The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may have jeopardized its long-running case against Ripple.

SEC Misses Crucial Deadline

In a surprising misstep, the SEC appears to have missed the deadline  to file its appeal, failing to specify its objections to Judge Analisa Torres’ Aug. 7 ruling.

After submitting its notice of appeal on Oct. 2, the SEC had a 14-day window to file the requisite Forms C and D by Oct 16.

However, the commission failed to meet this critical milestone, leaving its appeal in limbo and potentially dismissed.

The omission is surprising given the SEC’s punctuality in all previous filings.

Failure to file the necessary documents on time could result in the appeal being dismissed, casting doubt on the commission’s ability to overturn Judge Torres’ decision.

However, there is some confusion over the precise deadline, which adds to the uncertainty.

The Deadline Confusion

The SEC’s apparent failure to meet the deadline to file its appeal has sparked debate and speculation among legal experts and the XRP community.

At the heart of the controversy is whether the 14-day deadline includes weekends and bank holidays.

While there is some speculation that the 14-day window does not include bank holidays and weekends, legal precedence suggests that court deadlines typically include weekends and holidays unless explicitly stated otherwise.

Since Oct. 16 did not coincide with a holiday, the SEC had no grounds for an extension, leaving its oversight unexplained.

Adding to the confusion, reports emerged  that the filing was docketed and acknowledged on Oct. 4, which would have pushed the deadline to Oct. 18, giving the SEC an additional two days to file.

Despite these conflicting accounts, sources close to the matter have told CCN that the official Notice of Appeal (NOA) date is indeed Oct. 2, which would put the deadline at Oct. 16.

“The only hope the SEC has is for the court to consider Columbus Day a national public holiday,” a source noted. “I don’t think that’s the case.”

Ripple executives have echoed similar sentiments , sharing a timeline that suggests the SEC had until Oct. 16 to file its appeal plan.

Other reports suggest the Oct. 4 filing  making rounds on social media is not referring to Form C but to another document.

A former SEC employee  has also weighed in, pointing out that the Oct. 4 document is merely an acknowledgment that allows the court to override the 14-day-from-notice due date but not for Form C, which appears to be inflexible.

This suggests that the SEC may have indeed missed the deadline.

SEC and Ripple did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A Tactic To Disrupt Ripple?

The XRP community has been abuzz  with speculation that the SEC’s failure to file Form C could signal its defeat in the case and potentially pave the way for a settlement.

Many observers following the case were confused by the SEC’s failure to meet the deadline, especially given its track record of timely filings in the case.

For instance, the deadline to file the motion of appeal was Oct. 7, but the SEC had filed it on October 2, a full week ahead of schedule.

The SEC’s misstep may have jeopardized its three-year legal battle against Ripple, potentially leading to the dismissal of its appeal and the closure of the case.

Meanwhile, Ripple filed its cross-appeal on Oct. 10, 2024, but the lack of clarity on the SEC’s arguments may complicate its defense.

While Ripple must proceed with its appeal regardless of the delay, this development has raised questions about the SEC’s legal strategy. Some analysts have speculated  that the delay might be a deliberate tactic to disrupt Ripple’s response.

As the situation unfolds, one thing is clear: the SEC has injected a new layer of uncertainty into the case, leaving many to wonder what lies ahead for the regulator and Ripple.

This is a developing story and will be updated.