One Vital Metric Trump’s ‘Opening Up America Again’ Plan Ignores

Trump's 'Opening Up America Again' phases don't factor in coronavirus testing, allowing states with out of control outbreaks to reopen.

Coronavirus cases will rise when the economy starts to open. But without adequate testing and tracking, that could quickly go from being a small trade-off for economic growth to another health crisis | Source: AP Photo/Patrick Semansky

  • Opening Up America Again doesn’t take testing positivity rates into account.
  • That means states across America can reopen without a full picture of the severity of their outbreak.
  • Testing should play a key role in reopening procedures.

There was something curiously absent from Donald Trump’s new “Opening Up America Again” plan: coronavirus testing guidelines.

Instead, states are allowed to move through a three-phase plan of lifting lockdown measures when they’ve seen a decrease in the number of new cases.

But that’s the wrong metric to focus on when it comes to evaluating the scope of this epidemic.

Trump’s ‘Reopen America’ Scheme Is Premature

More testing could cause an increase in daily new cases, but it provides a better picture of how bad a coronavirus outbreak is in a particular area.

In regions where the virus is under control, a larger number of tests should yield a lower positivity rate. The positivity rate is the number of people who test positive for coronavirus compared to the total number of tests.

If coronavirus were truly under control, casting a wider testing net should produce more negative results – and a lower positivity rate. That hasn’t been the case in the United States.

The nation’s positivity rate is currently 20% after testing around 1% of the total population. What’s more, America ramped up its coronavirus testing significantly over the past month, but the rate of positives went up.

Compare that to other countries with similar testing percentages, and the case for reopening the economy begins to flounder. Among the world’s wealthy economies, only Britain’s 30% positivity rate is higher. Even Italy, whose outbreak was one of the worst in the world, has a positivity rate of just 15%.

U.S. States Set to Reopen Haven’t Controlled their Coronavirus Outbreaks

That suggests that in America, only people with a high probability of having coronavirus are being tested. There are likely many people with mild symptoms – or no symptoms at all – who aren’t being counted. Evaluating “Open Up America Again” in that light exposes the danger of allowing states to open without adequate testing.

Speaking about his plans on Thursday, President Trump noted that some states would be able to open ahead of May 1, and several others who were “in good shape” could open at the end of the month.

There’s more to the U.S. coronavirus outbreak than just total number of cases. | Source: The Guardian

Ohio Governor Mike DeWine says his state will be ready to open on May 1. As of Thursday, the state had conducted roughly 74,000 tests, yielding a positivity rate of 11%. That’s just 4 percentage points lower than Italy’s.

In Colorado, Governor Jared Polis has said he hopes to start opening on April 26 when his state’s stay-at-home order expires. Colorado’s positivity rate stands at 21%.

These states have tested 0.6% and 0.7% of their populations, respectively.

Learning from Coronavirus in Europe is Essential

Contrast this with Europe’s lockdown exit strategy.

In Germany, the number of coronavirus tests conducted is nearing 2 million, or roughly 2.5% of the nation’s population. The positivity rate is approximately 8%.

Germany’s positivity rate is falling as more coronavirus testing is performed. | Source: Statista

According to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, that’s comforting enough to start lifting some lockdown measures while continuing to ramp up testing.

Yet when Germany started easing restrictions, the number of new cases rose – as did the daily death toll. This underscores the delicate balance between economic survival and managing public health.

In Spain, where some business activity resumed this week, the number of coronavirus cases saw its largest increase in nearly a week.

The bottom line? Coronavirus cases will rise when the U.S. economy starts to open. Without adequate testing and tracking, that could quickly evolve from a small tradeoff for economic growth into another health crisis.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of

Last modified: September 25, 2020 8:41 PM

Laura Hoy: Laura has been working as financial journalist covering US markets for more than a decade. Her work can be found in a wide variety of publications including Yahoo Finance, InvestorPlace, Nasdaq and Benzinga. Contact her at, see her LinkedIn profile here.