Home / Sports News & Opinions / Michael Vick Doesn’t Deserve Pro Bowl Honors – But Not for the Reason You Think

Michael Vick Doesn’t Deserve Pro Bowl Honors – But Not for the Reason You Think

Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:20 PM
Travis Pulver
Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:20 PM
  • Michael Vick was named an honorary captain for this year’s NFL Pro Bowl.
  • Vick’s inclusion angered many fans. It has led to several petitions being created at Change.org, demanding the NFL retract the honor.
  • Vick shouldn’t be a Pro Bowl captain, but it’s not because of his dog-fighting scandal.

It may seem hard to believe sometimes, but the NFL does occasionally try to do the right thing. We’ll never know for sure, but the league may have meant well when it set up the workout for Colin Kaepernick.

But to many NFL fans, no defense or explanation can justify naming Michael Vick an honorary captain for the Pro Bowl this year. Yes, he was an exceptional player in his prime, but he isn’t remembered most for playing football – but for his criminal dog-fighting ring .

As could be expected, many fans are angry and are demanding the NFL retract the honor.

Petitions, Petitions, and More Angry Petitions

Last week, the NFL announced that the honorary captains for the Pro Bowl this year would be Terrell Davis, Darrell Green, Bruce Smith and Michael Vick. It didn’t take long for the first petition to pop up on Change.org, demanding the NFL remove Vick as Pro Bowl captain.

This one created by Aladdin Nation has 180,000+ supporters . Another one that was started by Joanna Lind  has 250,000+ supporters, and various others have accrued around 10,000 signatures.

michael vick dog-fighting petition nfl pro bowl
More than 250,000 people have demanded that the NFL retract Michael Vick’s Pro Bowl honors. | Source: Change.org 

The message on each was essentially the same: Michael Vick’s involvement in the illegal dog-fighting ring should block him from receiving any NFL honors.

They don’t care that he served 18 months in federal prison of the 23-month sentence he received. The work he has done since in support of the Humane Society and an anti-dog fighting bill  means little. They just remember all the harm he did to so many dogs.

While many petitions were calling for his removal, other NFL fans still support Vick. They recognized his crime, but then also gave him credit for paying his debt to society.

In their minds, he deserves a second chance. Since he has appeared to reform, they have no problem with the NFL honoring him.

Michael Vick Doesn’t Deserve the Honor (But Not Because of His Crime)

Even if his record was squeaky clean, Vick still never should have been named an honorary captain in the first place.

Yes, he was an exciting, dynamic player in his prime. But take his resume and compare it to the other three captains this year, and it doesn’t hold up to scrutiny.

Vick’s resume features one trip to the NFC Conference Championship and four Pro Bowls.

That’s it.

Terrell Davis, Darrell Green, and Bruce Smith are all Hall of Famers. Davis won two Super Bowls and was the MVP of one. Green played in three Super Bowls, winning two, and is a seven-time Pro Bowler.

Smith’s resume includes four Super Bowls, two Defensive Player of the Year awards, and 11 Pro Bowls. He also holds the all-time career record for sacks.

Last year’s honorary captains were just as impressive —and more impressive than Vick.

Don’t Expect the NFL to Make a Change

People can demand the NFL remove Michael Vick as a Pro Bowl captain. But more than likely, the NFL will do nothing.

The league has a long history of giving guys who commit crimes or even go to prison a second chance. Lawrence Taylor is in the Hall of Fame. Quite a few players served timed and then played again afterward.

If a player can contribute and doesn’t commit any additional crimes, the NFL doesn’t care. Michael Vick has kept his nose clean, so the NFL will likely have his back.