Home / Archive / Pepsi Thrives While Coke Fizzles in Worst Trading Day Since 2008

Pepsi Thrives While Coke Fizzles in Worst Trading Day Since 2008

Last Updated September 23, 2020 12:26 PM
Tedra DeSue
Last Updated September 23, 2020 12:26 PM

The legendary Coca-Cola Company has fallen on some hard times, and its officials aren’t seeing better days ahead.

Most understand its woes stem from consumers giving up their sugary soft drink addictions, but Coca-Cola is blaming something else that its main competitor, PepsiCo doesn’t see as that much of a problem.

Coca-Cola significantly lowered its outlook, saying that macroeconomics were among the headwinds that would continue to weigh on its sales. This logic seems to be unique to Coca-Cola, as PepsiCo officials didn’t call out macroeconomics as a major issue. It even raised its outlook.

Coca-Cola is the last of hundreds of companies reporting earnings. It doesn’t join the crowd of companies whose reports have helped move the stock market higher.

Dismal Days Ahead

When Coca-Cola reported  its Q4 2018 earnings Thursday, it said 2019 revenue growth would be lower than it was in 2018. It said was expected to fall to 4%.

Its net revenues declined 6% to $7.1 billion for the quarter. Revenues fell 10% to $31.9 billion for the year.

Fourth quarter and full year results were impacted by headwinds of 13% and 17%, respectively, from the combined impact of currency and the refranchising of company-owned bottling operations, the company reported.

Can Coca-Cola Really Blame The World For Fiscal Woes?

Back in the day, Coca-Cola commercials included lyrics from a song that said “we’d like to teach the world to sing….We’d like to buy the world a coke, and keep it company.”

Today, it’s singling out countries around the world as being partly to blame for its slowing sales. Coca-Cola CEO John Quincey said:

Looking ahead, we’re seeing the impact of some increasing uncertainty and volatility in global macroeconomic conditions. Clearly, there are places where weakness is apparent. Argentina went down quite strongly in the fourth quarter and that’s likely to continue in the first half of this year. Turkey, very similarly, some parts of the Middle East.

If It’s Macroeconomics, Why Is PepsiCo Doing Fine?

Coca-Cola lowered its guidance, but PepsiCo announced it was boosting its guidance when it issued its Q4 2018 earnings Friday morning.

PepsiCo’s chief financial officer Hugh Johnson discussed his company’s rosy guidance on CNBC this morning.

PepsiCo’s macros are largely fine around the world. Of course, there are always going to be one or two areas of dislocation, but by and large we think the macros are benign. Perhaps they are a little bit slower than what they’ve been for the last couple of years. But certainly, for a consumer stable company, it has not been noticeably so.

PepsiCo chairman and CEO Ramon Laguarta said in a statement  on Friday morning.

Our 2019 EPS performance is expected to be impacted by incremental investments that are intended to further strengthen the business, lapping a number of 2018 strategic asset sales and refranchising gains and an increased core effective tax rate in 2019.

The tempered guidance appears to have been factored in by the market, as PepsiCo’s 1.4% decline after Coke’s earnings announcement seems to have taken the sting out of PepsiCo’s report, according to TheStreet .

Coca-Cola’s stock slumped 8% following its dismal guidance.

Coca Cola shares took a substantial dive after the beverage giant lowered its guidance. Source: Chart via TradingView

PepsiCo’s guidance sent its stock higher.

PepsiCo shares are a picture in contrast to rival Coca-Cola with a confident forecast. | Chart via TradingView