Giants Better Off With Eli Manning Rather Than Daniel Jones, for Now

To better prepare Jones for the future, the team may be better off letting Manning play in the present.

Posted in: Op-edSports News
Published:
December 18, 2019 1:14 AM UTC
  • When the Giants drafted Daniel Jones with the No. 6 pick in the draft, the writing was on the wall for Eli Manning. The end was near.
  • No one expected it to come as early as it did this season back in Week Three, but the call was made, and the Daniel Jones era began.
  • But to better prepare Jones for the future, the team may be better off letting Manning play in the present.

The New York Giants could potentially have a very tough question on their hands this week. Do they insert rookie Daniel Jones back into the lineup or let longtime veteran Eli Manning have at least one more start?

Whether the question will need answering depends on Jones’ injured ankle. Is he 100 percent and ready to go? Or would it be better for him to let it rest longer?

Making A Case For (and against) Daniel Jones

Jones is the future of the franchise. For the outlook on that future to improve, Jones needs to get reps, not just in practice but in games. The season is already lost, but Jones could still get some valuable work in if he is healthy enough to play.

Advertisement

The injury occurred back in Week 13 during the loss to the Green Bay Packers. The team called it a high ankle sprain and said that it could take two-to-four weeks for Jones to recover. That means he could return this week or miss the remainder of the season.

Jones is out of the walking boot and resumed practice in a limited capacity last week. So it is not hard to imagine him getting cleared to play this week.

The experience would be beneficial to his development if he is ready to go. But the risk involved in playing on a tender ankle does not outweigh the reward. Do they want Jones to get better? Of course, but they also don’t want him to go down with a severe injury.

If he does and the injury is bad enough, that could mean one more season with Eli Manning. While the fans love their two-time Super Bowl-winning quarterback, they are ready for the future.

Besides, the fans got to see Manning play at home last week.

He didn’t play great, but he had some moments, and the team won. The fans gave him a nice send-off and essentially said goodbye. With his record as a starter back to .500 (117-117), maybe it is time for Manning to leave well enough alone.

Making A Case For Eli Manning

The nostalgic fan inside all of us would love to see Manning finish the season and then ride off into the sunset. But Giants head coach Pat Shurmur doesn’t have the luxury of nostalgia. If he is going to do his job, he needs to look to the future of the team.

Advertisement

To that end, he needs to start Manning over Jones.

Jones got to start 10 games, which is about what he played in college. At this point, especially with the struggles he has had, including an eight-game losing streak, he may be mentally exhausted. We already know his ankle isn’t 100 percent, but the more significant issue in these last two games could easily be mental fatigue.

So, he might not even be in the mental space he needs to be in if he is going to benefit from two additional starts.

Just Let Eli Start!

Yes, the send-off was great Sunday, but Manning has said he still wants to play. Since it may be better for the overall health and development of Jones to sit for these last two, why not let him?

Shurmur recognized the possibility last week that Manning could start the final two:

Advertisement

This is a rare opportunity where doing the right thing for a young player is indulging in a little nostalgia. Make it happen, Shurmur—let Eli play!

This article was edited by Gerelyn Terzo.

Last modified: January 22, 2020 11:40 PM UTC

Travis Pulver @FatManWriting

Travis graduated from Ball State University in Muncie, Indiana, with a master's in Political Science. Prior to that, he attended IU Purdue in Indianapolis, Indiana, where he earned his bachelor's degree in Political Science and earned his first degree at Texas A & M in Galveston, TX, a BS in Maritime Administration. You can contact him on Twitter at @FatManWriting. Over the last few years, Travis has worked for several news-oriented sites that focused on sports, especially football, baseball, basketball, and to a lesser extent, boxing and MMA. Having grown up in the football-crazed state of Texas, football is his first love. According to his mother, he was more excited to watch NFL and college games as a baby than Sesame Street or Mickey Mouse. His passion for sports quickly spread to baseball (favorite team is the Houston Astros), basketball, and track and field as a kid. It wasn’t until his college years that he discovered the tremendous game of rugby. He currently lives in the United States in Indiana (is a basketball fan but hates going to the Indy 500) with his wife and two adorable kids.

Show comments