Dow Rebounds as Stunning Jobs Data Distract from Manufacturing Recession

Josiah Wilmoth @Y3llowb1ackbird
November 1, 2019 13:41 UTC
  • The Dow, S&P 500, and Nasdaq all rebounded on Friday, ending the week on a high note and starting off the new month with a bang.
  • A surprisingly strong jobs report emboldened stock market bulls, as the economy beat estimates despite pressure from the GM strike.
  • The enthusiastic response to the jobs report distracted from other worrisome economic data releases.

The Dow bounced back from its Halloween haunting on Friday after a stunning jobs report distracted from foreboding economic data.

Dow Snaps Toward a Recovery After Strong Non-Farm Payrolls Data

Wall Street’s three major indices rose in unison. The Dow Jones Industrial Average surged 250.38 points or 0.93% to 27,296.61, more than erasing its Oct. 31 losses.

Bullish jobs data launched the Dow toward a triple-digit recovery. | Source: Yahoo Finance

The S&P 500 jumped 24.24 points or 0.8%. Now trading at 3,061.66, the large-cap index has the potential to close at yet another record high.

The Nasdaq recorded a similar bounce, adding 73.66 points or 0.89% to achieve a new all-time high at 8,366.22.

The gold price declined by 0.17% as equities spiked. The yellow metal had basked in Thursday’s risk-off climate, which allowed it to reclaim the psychologically-significant $1,500 level.

Stock Market Reacts to Spectacular Jobs Report

A surprisingly-strong jobs report emboldened Dow bulls, who had already prepared to shrug off any dismal statistics as outliers caused by the prolonged General Motors strike.

However, those excuses turned out not to be necessary, because nonfarm payrolls jumped by 128,000 anyway, easily smashing the Dow Jones economist estimate of 75,000.

Even better, August and September payrolls data were both revised upward, resulting in a net addition of 95,000 more jobs. The economy is now creating an average of 167,000 jobs per month, down from 223,000 in 2018.

Manufacturing Recession Hangs Over Economy

In isolation, Friday’s jobs report would be expected to fortify economic forecasts against recession warnings. However, the manufacturing sector is already in a recession, and the apparent breakdown in trade war optimism suggests that the gloomy picture won’t change anytime soon.

This morning, the ISM Manufacturing PMI report revealed that factory activity had contracted for a third straight month. PMI came in at 48.3, slightly below the 49.0 economists had expected. Readings below 50 indicate contraction.

PMI, a measure of business confidence, contracted for the third straight month. | Source: Trading Economics

Survey participants expressed concern about weak demand. As one respondent told ISM,

“Customer demand is down, and we are expecting a very soft fourth quarter, without much relief in sight for Q1. Suppliers report the continued rise in labor costs, which are ultimately reflected in the rising product costs.”

The poor data weren’t entirely surprising. On Thursday, Chicago PMI – a key measure of regional business sentiment – plunged to a nearly four year low of 43.2, missing economist estimates by a wide margin. Chicago PMI is more volatile than the broader ISM Manufacturing report, but it’s difficult to disregard a print of 43.2.

To be sure, manufacturing comprises a much leaner slice of the US economy than in the sector’s glory days. A recent Bloomberg report found that, contrary to President Trump’s promise to make American manufacturing great again, US factory output’s contribution to GDP floundered at 11% in the second quarter– its lowest point in 72 years.

Notably, today’s non-farms payrolls report revealed that the manufacturing sector had lost 36,000 jobs, though that figure was intensified by the GM strike.

Ironically, the industry’s decline is a silver lining for the economy’s overall picture, given that PMI printed readings below 50 in each of the past three months – underperforming economist forecasts on all three occasions.

Solid consumer data figures continue to buttress GDP against the manufacturing slowdown. However, consumer data tends to lag business indicators, and – strong job creation notwithstanding – business investment has begun to decline.

Click here for a live Dow Jones Industrial Average chart.

This article was edited by Sam Bourgi.

Last modified: November 1, 2019 15:01 UTC

More of: Dow Jones
Josiah Wilmoth @Y3llowb1ackbird

Josiah is the US Editor at CCN, where he focuses on financial markets. He has written over 2,000 articles since joining CCN in 2014. His work has also been featured on ZeroHedge, Yahoo Finance, and Investing.com. He lives in rural Virginia. Follow him on Twitter @y3llowb1ackbird or email him directly at josiah.wilmoth(at)ccn.com.