Home / Markets News & Opinions / Dow Climbs But Critical Stimulus Benefit Hurtles Toward Termination

Dow Climbs But Critical Stimulus Benefit Hurtles Toward Termination

Last Updated September 23, 2020 2:08 PM
Francois Aure
Last Updated September 23, 2020 2:08 PM
  • The Dow Jones rose toward session highs in late afternoon trading after struggling to mount a convincing rally for most of the day on Wednesday.
  • Pandemic and stimulus concerns cast a shadow over Wall Street.
  • Ritholtz Wealth Management sees low yields continuing to drive capital into the stock market.

The Dow Jones rose mid-week, although other corners of the stock market struggled as the $600 weekly federal unemployment benefit hurtled closer to expiration.

Raising the stakes even further, President Trump delivered an uncharacteristically-dire warning about the state of the pandemic.

Dow Jones Rises as Wall Street Nervously Awaits More Stimulus

Stocks broadly rose, though gains in most sectors were muted until a late-session boost sent share prices higher.

By 3:25 pm ET, the Dow Jones had gained 126.95 points. The 0.47% leap lifted the index to 26,967.35.

dow jones today, stock market
The Dow Jones struggled for most of the session Wednesday before mounting a triple-digit advance in late afternoon trading. | Source: Yahoo Finance 

The S&P 500 rose 0.4% to 3,270.33, while the Nasdaq reversed earlier losses to eke out a slight 0.09% gain.

Today’s U.S. economic data dump  was dominated by housing. Existing home sales jumped 21% in June, while weekly mortgage applications rose 4.1%.

Elsewhere, crude oil inventories unexpectedly rose by nearly 5 million barrels. This put pressure on energy stocks.

The outlook for crude demand is murky, particularly given Donald Trump’s evolving tone on the pandemic. Echoing his tone from April, the president warned:

Things are going to worsen before they get better.

Already armed with a clearer message on masks, Trump’s rapid shift comes amid a spate of poor polling  and the continued spread of the virus .

Even more pressing for Dow bulls are concerns about the impending expiration of the $600 weekly federal unemployment boost.

This money raised incomes for a significant portion of claimants, and – for all its potential downsides  – helped steady the economy.

Will Stimulus Expiration Halt the Retail Trading Boom?

Raising benefits so drastically may have created a strange sense of well-being in the marketplace and fueled the retail trading mania.

With top Republican lawmakers warning a follow-up stimulus bill might not arrive  until after the benefits expire, investors must grapple with the potential market impact of millions of people suffering an income shock.

William Katz, an analyst at TD Ameritrade, is skeptical that the retail investment boom can continue . He said in a recent report:

If this is indeed the new normal, our stand-alone and pro-forma estimates could be sharply too low. But, history would suggest such engagement may not be fully sustainable, leaving us a bit in the show-us camp.

There’s no doubt more stimulus is coming. The question is when. Republicans won’t be in any position to hash out a compromise with Democrats  until they address their own in-fighting .

Failure to reach a timely agreement could blind a stock market that has been confident of an additional fiscal package since before the last one was released.

Are Plunging Yields Providing a Massive Stock Market Support?

Stock market, S&P 500
80% of S&P 500 stocks yield more than the U.S. 10-Year Treasury note. | Source: Ritholtz Wealth Management 

While analysts scramble to affix bullish storylines to the stock market, there could be a far simpler explanation behind what continues to drive the Dow higher.

Michael Batnick, director of research at Ritholtz Wealth Management, says ultra-low interest rates are forcing income investors to pile into stocks. 

He explains:

The 10-year treasury is offering investors a juicy 60 basis points of income, or $60 for every $10,000 invested… Nearly 80% of stocks in the S&P 500 have a higher dividend yield than the 10-year treasury rate. The idea that you can generate more income from stocks makes perfect sense to investors from the first half of the 20th century and absolutely no sense to investors from the second half of it.

Dow 30 Stocks: Pfizer Soars After U.S. Vaccine Agreement

The Dow 30  was sturdy on Wednesday.

Pfizer stock (+4.8%) enjoyed a classic vaccine-related bump after news broke that the U.S. had agreed to pay $2 billion for 100 million doses of its drug. That assumes one of the four vaccines they’re developing with BioNTech proves to be both safe and effective.

It still isn’t clear who will win this race to bring a viable vaccine to market. The stakes are higher than ever for Pfizer shareholders, who could be left exposed if disappointments strike down the road.

Apple stock was mostly flat on the day, anchoring the index as it struggled higher.

Goldman Sachs and Exxon Mobil were the weakest stocks in the Dow Jones. Each lost more than 2%, erasing part of their recent rallies.