Home / Markets News & Opinions / Dow Bloodbath Intensifies After Brutal Economic Data Dump

Dow Bloodbath Intensifies After Brutal Economic Data Dump

Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:06 PM
Josiah Wilmoth
Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:06 PM

The Dow and broader US stock market quivered on Thursday, as Wall Street grew increasingly fearful that upcoming data readings will augur the impending conclusion of the US economy’s longest-ever expansion.

Those fears were partially realized this morning when a reading of the services economy flashed a bright red flag.

Dow Lurches Toward Third Straight Loss

Wall Street’s major indices plunged for a third straight day on Thursday. By 10:13 am ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average had crashed 303.1 points or 1.16% to 25,775.52.

dow jones industrial average chart
The Dow plunged for a third straight day after a report on the services sector came in far lower than expected. | Source: Yahoo Finance

The S&P 500 and Nasdaq relinquished earlier gains, falling 1.06% to 2,857.08 and 0.99% to 7,708.27.

US Economy Teeters on the Brink

The Dow and its peers struggled to recover from their two-day bloodletting, as concerns about crucial economic data reports paralyzed investors.

On Thursday, ISM published its September nonmanufacturing purchasing managers’ index (PMI), which measures the health of the economy’s services sector. As economists feared, the reading came in far lower than expected, printing a 52.6  versus the Dow Jones consensus estimate of 55.3.

ISM nonmanufacturing PMI
Today’s weak ISM reading suggests that the manufacturing recession has spilled into the broader economy. | Source: Trading Economics 

Today’s ISM reading still indicates services sector expansion, but analysts are concerned that it missed estimates by such a wide margin.

“If for some reason, [ISM services] drops to 52, 53, anything that’s below consensus … that would raise the concern that services output is beginning to slow as well, and you’d get that same picture if employment is weak as well,” Michael Gapen, chief U.S. economist at Barclays, told CNBC  before the report’s release.

Services account for more than 80% of the US economy, so Wall Street will likely take the report as a significant recession warning.

It’s particularly concerning since it comes just two days after the ISM purchasing managers’ index (PMI) unexpectedly plunged to its lowest level in a decade (47.8), contracting for a second straight month and raising significant concerns about the state of US manufacturing.

US ISM PMI report
The manufacturing sector has contracted for two straight months. | Source: Trading Economics 

The unexpected PMI miss thrust the Dow toward a 343.79 point decline on Oct. 1, which marked the index’s worst loss since August. That mark stood for precisely one session, as the Dow plummeted 494.42 points the next day.

Weakening Labor Market Threatens Consumer Spending

Equally as important is Friday’s nonfarm payrolls report, which investors fear will confirm a labor market slowdown.

Wednesday’s ADP private payrolls report found that the private sector had added just 135,000 jobs in September, and the 2019 monthly average now stands at 145,000 jobs – a steep dropoff from 2018’s monthly average of 214,000.

adp private sector payrolls report
Private sector employment growth has slowed down considerably since the second quarter. | Source: Trading Economics 

Last week, a Commerce Department report revealed that US consumer spending had virtually stalled in August, rising just 0.1% as job growth waned.

A strong services sector and robust consumer spending have buttressed the US economy throughout the trade war. However, the poor ISM nonmanufacturing reading, combined with a weakening labor market, could expose vulnerabilities in an economic expansion that is now the longest in US history.

Click here for a live Dow Jones Industrial Average chart