Home / Markets News & Opinions / Dow Winning Streak Hits 3 as U.S. Suffers Historic Unemployment Crisis

Dow Winning Streak Hits 3 as U.S. Suffers Historic Unemployment Crisis

Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:46 PM
Ben Brown
Last Updated September 23, 2020 1:46 PM
  • The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) rallied for a third straight day, despite some historically grisly economic data.
  • Traders shook off the worst jobless claims report ever, which saw nearly 3.3 million Americans file for unemployment benefits.
  • Analysts say this is just the start as the dominos begin to fall across America.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) rallied for a third straight day on Thursday, as the worst jobless claims report in U.S. history  unexpectedly prompted investors to breathe a nervous sigh of relief.

More than 3.28 million Americans filed unemployment claims – a record increase of 1,064.2% from the previous week. Judging from today’s stock market upswing, investors apparently feared the number would come in even worse.

Unfortunately, analysts say the worst is yet to come for the U.S. stock market. Speaking to CNBC, RBC Capital Markets’ Lori Calvasina said she’s looking for the S&P 500 to fall back to at least 2,000  – a drop of 20% from here.

I think there’s a good chance that [Monday] probably wasn’t [the bottom]. What we know about bottoms is that they do take time … The market was starting to tell us that something more onerous than an ordinary recession is at hand. And I think that possibility is still out there.

Morgan Stanley’s Lisa Shalett agreed:

I don’t think we’re ready to declare a bottom either.

Dow defies ugly unemployment surge to post third straight gain

All of Wall Street’s major indices rose during the Thursday morning session.

  • The Dow bounced 398.5 points or 1.88% to 21,599.05.
  • The S&P 500 rose 2.04% to 2,526.15.
  • The Nasdaq ticked 1.76% higher to 7,514.60.
dow jones industrial average, stock market
The Dow rose for a third straight day on Thursday. | Source: Yahoo Finance

One reason the Dow Jones largely ignored the jobless claims data may be that a $2 trillion rescue package is finally making its way through the Senate.

Economists hope this rescue package – which includes a $500 billion lending program for businesses  – will help companies keep employees on their payroll despite the crisis.

California: 1 million unemployed

Stock futures had struggled overnight after the state of California reported over 1 million unemployment claims, a shocking rise from just 50,000 in December.

Nationwide estimates had suggested a figure as high as 4 million.

We’re coming up with a number that could be over 3 million and perhaps as high as 3.4 million – Ron Temple, Lazard Asset Management, NY.

Morgan Stanley unemployment estimates
Morgan Stanley’s estimate of 3.1 million jobless claims on Thursday dwarfed any weekly number in recent recessions, but still undershot the actual figure of 3.28 million. | Source: Morgan Stanley

Workers have lost their jobs across all sectors of society from the service industry to travel to the self-employed. This is the beginning of a longer recession and investors are reluctant to go back in the water. Temple continues:

That kind of magnitude of an increase in unemployment and shock to the system, it’s way too early to be trying to call a bottom or prognosticate how much further (the market) could go down.

The Dow Jones probably hasn’t bottomed yet

Thursday jobless claims is the first indicator of the U.S. economy retracting. And analysts say it’s just the beginning . Mohannad Aama at Beam Capital Management said firms are restructuring and downsizing across the country:

Any number we get on Thursday won’t give an accurate picture of what is going on out there with downsizing decisions being discussed in corporate America as we speak.

With gut-wrenching economic data on the way and more coronavirus headlines, Wall Street is bracing for a deeper market bloodbath as the crisis continues.

Coronavirus impact will get worse before it gets better

The news cycle is expected to get worse as America becomes the global hotspot for the novel coronavirus. Investors say they won’t get fully back into the market until there’s an end in sight . Tarek Fadlallah at Nomura Asset Management told CNBC:

I wouldn’t be rushing straight back in at these levels … The news flow in the next two weeks will get worse, especially as we see the infection rates increase in the US and Europe. Once we start to see an improvement in those numbers … Once I see the news flow improving and I can see an end to this situation, then whatever the level is, you have a look at that and make a decision.

With additional reporting by Josiah Wilmoth